Legal analysisof the disputein relation todiscriminationon the importof agricultural equipmentin the frameworkof the GATT
36 22
Keywords:
WTO, GATT, the Great Britain, Italy, disputes, finance, credit, agricultural equipment, subsidies, trade treaties, economy, goods sale, purchase, transportation, agreement, import, duties,Abstract
This article discusses thedispute which has arisenonthe substantiveissuesbetween the «Great Britain and Italy in respect ofagricultural equipment.» The paper analyzes thecharacteristics ofthe dispute.Practiceorgan of the WorldTrade OrganizationDispute Settlementin such casesis of particular importanceforthe Republic of Kazakhstanin foreign tradewhich, import of agricultural equipmentoccupies a large place. Based onArticle III ofthe GATT, the author presentsa possibleresolutionof the dispute, based on the integrated use ofdifferent methods ofinterpretation, including comparative legalway. The main rule, which was establishedon the basis ofthe present disputeis the factthatstate aidto economic entitiesmayviolate the principle ofdiscrimination.Resulting ina set of proposalsto resolvethe dispute.References
1 Dispute settlement: Jonathan t. Fried. 2013 in WTO Dispute Settlement // DSҰ resmi sayty: http://www.wto.org/english/
tratop_e/dispu_e/jfried_13_e.htm (14.11.2014 zh.).
2 Kazakstan Respublikasynyn Prezidentí-Yelbasy N.Ə. Nazarbayevtyn Kazakstan khalkyna Zholdauy «Əleumettíkekonomikalyk
zhanġyrtu – Kazakstan damuynyn basty baġyty» 2012 zhylġy 27 kantar Kazakstan Respublikasy Prezidentínín
resmi sayty: http://www.akorda.kz/kz/page/kazakstan-respulikasynyn-prezidenti-n-a-nazarbaevtyn-kazakstan-khalkynazholdauy-27-01-2012zh_1341124121 (14.11.2014 zh.).
3 Kazakstan Respublikasynyn Prezidentí N.Ə.Nazarbayevtyn Kazakstan khalkyna Zholdauy. 2010 zhylġy 29 kantar. «Zhana
onzhyldyk – zhana ekonomikalyk өrleu – Kazakstannyn zhana mumkíndíkterí» Kazakstan Respublikasy Prezidentínín
resmi sayty: http://www.akorda.kz/kz/page/kazakstan-respublikasynyn-prezidenti-n-a-nazarbaevtyn-khalykka-zholdauy-
2010-zh_1341123470 (14.11.2014 zh.).
4 «Kazakstan Respublikasy Ekonomika zhəne byudzhettík zhosparlau ministrlígínín 2014-2018 zhyldarġa arnalġan strategiyalyk
zhospary turaly Kazakstan Respublikasy Ukímetínín 2013 zhylġy 31 zheltoksandaġy № 1587 kaulysy». «Ədílet»
Kazakstan Respublikasy normativtík kukyktyk aktílerínín akparattyk-kukyktyk zhuyyes resmi sayty: http://adilet.zan.kz/kaz/
docs/P1300001587 (14.11.2014 zh.).
5 Chleny VTO i nablyudateli 160 stran-chlenov na 26 iyunya 2014 // Tsentr ekspertizy po voprosam VTO Rossiya i Vsemirnaya
torgovaya organizatsiya Rezhim dostupa: onlayn http://www.wto.ru/chto.asp?f=memb&t=7 (15.11.2014 zh.).
6 I talian Discrimination against Imported Agricultural Machinery, Report adopted on 23.10.1958 (L/833 – 7S/60). Rezhim
dostupa: onlayn http://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/dispu_e/58agrmch.pdf (15.11.2014 zh.).
7 Poluetkov A.B. VTO kak instrument ekonomicheskoy politiki stran-chlenov // Rossiyskiy vneshneekonomicheskiy vestnik.
– 006. – № 1 (Yanvar’). – S. 19. Rezhim dostupa: onlayn http://www.rfej.ru/rvv/id/2BE CE2/$file/19-25.pdf (18.11.2014 zh).
8 9th WTO ministerial conference, Bali, 2013 // Briefing note: Dispute settlement — force of argument, not argument of force.
DSU resmi sayty: http://www.wto.org/english/thewto_e /minist_e/mc9_e/brief_dispu_e.htm (19.11.2014 zh.).
tratop_e/dispu_e/jfried_13_e.htm (14.11.2014 zh.).
2 Kazakstan Respublikasynyn Prezidentí-Yelbasy N.Ə. Nazarbayevtyn Kazakstan khalkyna Zholdauy «Əleumettíkekonomikalyk
zhanġyrtu – Kazakstan damuynyn basty baġyty» 2012 zhylġy 27 kantar Kazakstan Respublikasy Prezidentínín
resmi sayty: http://www.akorda.kz/kz/page/kazakstan-respulikasynyn-prezidenti-n-a-nazarbaevtyn-kazakstan-khalkynazholdauy-27-01-2012zh_1341124121 (14.11.2014 zh.).
3 Kazakstan Respublikasynyn Prezidentí N.Ə.Nazarbayevtyn Kazakstan khalkyna Zholdauy. 2010 zhylġy 29 kantar. «Zhana
onzhyldyk – zhana ekonomikalyk өrleu – Kazakstannyn zhana mumkíndíkterí» Kazakstan Respublikasy Prezidentínín
resmi sayty: http://www.akorda.kz/kz/page/kazakstan-respublikasynyn-prezidenti-n-a-nazarbaevtyn-khalykka-zholdauy-
2010-zh_1341123470 (14.11.2014 zh.).
4 «Kazakstan Respublikasy Ekonomika zhəne byudzhettík zhosparlau ministrlígínín 2014-2018 zhyldarġa arnalġan strategiyalyk
zhospary turaly Kazakstan Respublikasy Ukímetínín 2013 zhylġy 31 zheltoksandaġy № 1587 kaulysy». «Ədílet»
Kazakstan Respublikasy normativtík kukyktyk aktílerínín akparattyk-kukyktyk zhuyyes resmi sayty: http://adilet.zan.kz/kaz/
docs/P1300001587 (14.11.2014 zh.).
5 Chleny VTO i nablyudateli 160 stran-chlenov na 26 iyunya 2014 // Tsentr ekspertizy po voprosam VTO Rossiya i Vsemirnaya
torgovaya organizatsiya Rezhim dostupa: onlayn http://www.wto.ru/chto.asp?f=memb&t=7 (15.11.2014 zh.).
6 I talian Discrimination against Imported Agricultural Machinery, Report adopted on 23.10.1958 (L/833 – 7S/60). Rezhim
dostupa: onlayn http://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/dispu_e/58agrmch.pdf (15.11.2014 zh.).
7 Poluetkov A.B. VTO kak instrument ekonomicheskoy politiki stran-chlenov // Rossiyskiy vneshneekonomicheskiy vestnik.
– 006. – № 1 (Yanvar’). – S. 19. Rezhim dostupa: onlayn http://www.rfej.ru/rvv/id/2BE CE2/$file/19-25.pdf (18.11.2014 zh).
8 9th WTO ministerial conference, Bali, 2013 // Briefing note: Dispute settlement — force of argument, not argument of force.
DSU resmi sayty: http://www.wto.org/english/thewto_e /minist_e/mc9_e/brief_dispu_e.htm (19.11.2014 zh.).
Downloads
Issue
Section
International relations and foreign policy
